The 1661 Sevenfold Sun of Gdańsk
AstronomyComments
What if the phenomenon required a specific combination of local pollution or unique ice crystal shapes present in 1661 Gdańsk? It might be a localized atmospheric anomaly rather than a failure of general physics.
This reminds me of the 1859 Carrington Event. Everyone saw the aurorae, but the only records that matter now are the ones from people who actually bothered to log the timings.
hevels account is uniquely detailed, but complex halos have been seen since.
If people have seen this since, why is Hevel the only one with a detailed record? Did everyone else just stop drawing their skies?
We have to remember that 17th century observers didn't have a standard vocabulary for atmospheric optics. Calling it unexplained by modern standards ignores that the description itself is the only data we have.
Hevel was a trained astronomer who used precise instruments. His sketches provide geometric data that doesn't fit current models.